Sunday, December 14, 2008

Book Review: Daughter of War

Daughter of War by Marsha Forchuk Skrypuch. (Grades 9+)

Kevork has to hide who he is. Marta bears the child of a man who raped her. Both of them could be killed if the truth came out. They are Armenians living in a country that hates them.

In Turkey during World War I, Armenians were rounded up and forced to live in concentration camps. They starved. Disease ran rampant. Missionaries from Germany and other countries tried to help, but even though Turkey was allied with Germany they were all in danger of being shut down.

No evidence of this genocide was allowed out of the country. If you were caught hiding Armenians, you were severely punished.

This is the backdrop for Daughter of War. It's brutally honest and tells the often untold story of a different genocide. We get many different points of view throughout the book, but the main stories are Kevork's and Marta's. After their parents were taken, Kevork and Marta met at a German orphanage where they fell in love. But adults and teens were not allowed to stay at orphanages and when Turks inspected the facility, Kevork and Marta were deported and separated.

Determined to find each other again, their stories take vastly different turns. Kevork disguises himself as an Arab and repairs shoes at a stall in the market. He's swept up in the resistance movement and sneaks money and other goods into concentration camps and hiding places. Marta, pregnant with an Arab's child, is delivered back to the orphanage and works to help the children there.

I give this novel high points for a gripping story about a genocide I knew little about. This book's not for the faint of heart as there are plenty of gory details about the abuse suffered by the Armenians and those who would protect them. Although the setting is rich with historical detail, I wish there had been more detail about the people and their cultures. Apparently this is a sequel to Nobody's Child, which I haven't read, so maybe if I had read that one I'd understand the conflicts a little better. Historical information is provided as a prologue, so I had some background but more details in the actual story would have made the characters come to life more than they did. Also, between the different narrators I found it hard to keep track of the passage of time.

Even with its flaws, I think this is a good story and an important one. You know those teens who devour anything having to do with WWII and the Holocaust? Try this one on them.

Check out Marsha Skrypuch's website and LiveJournal.

7 comments:

Steph said...

This sounds really good. Hmm... must look into adding it to the book mountains. Thanks for the rec, Abby!

Steph

Mama Monkey said...

Thanks for this review. I ordered a used copy of Nobody's Child. I'll give that a go first.

Marsha Skrypuch said...

Thanks so much for reading and reviewing Daughter of War, Abby!

Jen Robinson said...

I liked this one, too, Abby. It did make a lot more sense to me once I realized that it wasn't the first book about the characters, too. Because I kept wondering why these major dramatic things were only mentioned in passing (because they'd presumably been covered in the other books).

Jennie said...

Have you ever read The Road from Home by Kherdian? It's also about the Armenian genocide. I read it in late elementary school and it's a story that's stuck with me through the years.

mouse0715 said...

This was a pretty good book abby i have to admit, i had to read it for the white pine and i liked every part about it but mostly the love inbetween Marta and Kevork in the concentration camp, i love books like that, i deffinitly gonna have to take out the one before it.

Term papers said...

Thanks for share this information, It’s great to see good information being shared.Thanks for share this.