Thursday, January 7, 2010

Audiobook Effects: Good and Bad

First, the good:

Feed by M.T. Anderson, read by David Aaron Baker. (Grades 9+) Listening Library, 2008. Copy provided by my local library.

Okay, so not only is this an awesome, intense, well-written book, but the audiobook is really fantastic.

Abridged summary from publisher:

"We went to the moon to have fun, but the moon turned out to completely suck." So says Titus, a teenager whose ability to read, write, and even think for himself has been almost completely obliterated by his "feed", a transmitter implanted directly into his brain... But then Titus meets Violet, a girl who cares about what's happening to the world and challenges everything that Titus and his friends hold dear. A girl who decides to fight the feed."

Narrator David Aaron Baker does a great job with the voices, capturing the cadence of teen speech. That's essential because it's one thing that makes the story so great - it's set in the future and the kids deal with unique problems, but they still sound like teens. They act like teens. The characters felt completely real, even though they are traveling in flying cars and chatting with each other using the internet inside their brains.

The "special effects" in the recording were great, too, and really added to the listener's understanding. There's a slight echo effect when the characters are chatting each other, giving the voices a kind of tinny quality to differentiate from when they're speaking out loud. And throughout the book, you're periodically interrupted by snippets of commercials, "TV" shows, and news reports (just like you actually had a feed sending you constant information). These snippets sound like actual commercials and news reports. They're very, very well done and add to the overall atmosphere of the book.

The Feed makes a GREAT audiobook and I can't recommend it enough for teens and adults looking for a good listen. (Fair warning, there is a fair amount of foul language.)

(Many, many thanks to Kelly at Stacked for recommending it!!)

Now, for the bad:

The Giver by Lois Lowry, read by Ron Rifkin. (Grades 5-8.) Listening Library, 2001. Copy provided by my local library.

The Giver is one of my favorite books of all time, so I was excited to revisit it on a recent car trip.

Jonas lives in a future where people have embraced Sameness. At the age of 12, everyone is assigned a career by the panel of Elders that guides their community. When Jonas is assigned the most prestigious career, Receiver of Memories, he discovers the cracks in his Utopian community.

Ron Rifkin does a great job narrating the story. Characters have voices that are subtly different, enough so that you can tell them apart.

The problem here is that whenever something strange and "magical" happens (like the transferring of memories), there is this terrible, distracting music playing. I get that it's intended to set apart the special events, but I just found it distracting. I wished that the music would stop so I could listen to Rifkin's excellent narration. And the worst thing is that the scenes with the music are some of the most emotionally moving scenes in the book. Since I was already familiar with the story, I'd gear myself up for the big reveals, only to be totally annoyed by the swelling music.

Maybe someone who wasn't familiar with the story might find it useful, but I think Rifkin's narration would have been just fine alone. I'd definitely recommend picking up The Giver, but I'm afraid I can't wholeheartedly recommend the audiobook.

So there you have two different examples of audiobook effects - one greatly contributing to the experience and one greatly detracting from the experience. Can you think of any audiobooks with particularly good - or particularly bad - effects? Put 'em in the comments!

8 comments:

Amy said...

Thanks for the reviews! Feed is in my current pile of books to read, which gets bigger every day. I'm just about done listening to The Adoration of Jenna Fox, so I skipped on over to the OPAC and reserved the CD of Feed for myself. Can't wait.

Janssen said...

Oh, I hate music background too. Yuck.

Amy said...

Feed sounds fantastic, and as for The Giver in audio, I think I would probably agree with you. I am really distracted from the story by too many audio effects.

(I'm here for the Comment Challenge 2010. Neat blog!)

Mary Ann Scheuer said...

Thanks for the interesting reviews. I've been meaning to listen to Feed - so it's great to hear a thumbs up! (OK, that's really mixing metaphors)

Books we've loved don't always translate well into audiobooks. I tried listening to Wrinkle in Time, and just couldn't get into it. I couldn't connect with the witches' voices at all. And as a family we tried listening to Charlotte's Web, and also had trouble connecting to that on audio. Disappointing, but that's why individual reviews matter so much! Thanks again for sharing your reaction to Giver and Feed!

NatalieSap said...

I, too, loved Feed as an audiobook. I tried reading it in a print a couple times with no luck and was so glad that I gave the audio a try. Some books are really meant to be read aloud, and this is definitely one of them!

Anamaria (bookstogether) said...

That's too bad about the music on The Giver audio, since that would be a great book to listen to (and talk about) as a family. Thanks for letting us know!

bestbookihavenotread said...

Feed sounds fascinating. Thanks for the audiobook reviews! I always try to have one in the car. That is a bummer about the bad music in The Giver, since it's such a great book!

Debbie's World of Books said...

Great reviews. I bought Feed before the holidays but haven't had a chance to get to it yet.