Saturday, April 18, 2009

Thoughts about matches 7 & 8

Is it just me or has this week flown by? I can't believe they've announced all the Round 1 winners already!

In Match 7, Graceling faced The Underneath and Tamora Pierce chose Graceling. Personally, I loved both books (in very different ways) and I don't agree with Ms. Pierce's criticism that "it went on too long, meandering too much and losing a great deal of the dramatic tension in the main and secondary stories. Also, the violence and alcoholism are more suited to a YA than a middle grade book, while the characters are definitely middle grade."

But, as Ms. Pierce is the author of a stack of books with kick-butt heroines, it's no surprise to me that Katsa took this round.

Match 8 pitted The Lincolns against Nation with judge Ann Brashares picking The Lincolns for yet another nonfiction win. I have to say, it's great to see nonfiction making such a good showing in the first round. I also have to say that I didn't have a lot of stock in this particular match, although I did see Candace Fleming speak at Anderson's and she's adorable.

Another week, another round! I'll be writing up my picks this weekend!

1 comment:

Lisa Chellman said...

Interesting that they had Tamora Pierce judge a Graceling round, considering that Graceling reminded me of nothing so much as a Tamora Pierce novel on just about every dimension...

I still haven't managed to get through The Underneath myself. *ducks*