Thursday, March 6, 2008

Book Review: Blood on the River

Blood on the River: Jamestown 1607 by Elisa Carbone. (Grades 5-8)

Young Samuel Collier is an orphan with an attitude and no place to go. When he's arrested for stealing a locket that had once belonged to his mother, Samuel is put to work as a page for Captain John Smith who is bound for the New World. At first, Samuel is determined to live life as an island, to keep everyone out and stand alone. But soon Captain Smith helps him to realize that one cannot survive alone in the New World. It will take the entire James Town colony working together in order to survive. The problem is that the gentlemen in the colony, sent by the Virginia Company to look for gold or any other profit they can find, don't see things that way. They are determined to let the commoners do the work and hog all the rations, living much as they were accustomed to back in England.

Captain Smith speaks out against this and is immediately disliked by the rich members of the colony. But Smith is the only one able to sustain a tenuous peace with the local native tribes, so he continues to lead. Smith teaches Samuel skills like sword fighting and the native language. And as life continues in James Town, Samuel sees the "savages" save the colonists time and time again. But not all the colonists are convinced that peace with the natives is necessary to their survival...

A meticulously researched historical novel, Blood on the River really takes you back to 1607, to the sights, sounds, and smells of Jamestown. Although it was a bit slow at first, once the colonists got to America and began interacting with the local Indian tribes, I found it fascinating. I especially liked the details Carbone included about the natives' appearance and traditions and the reasons behind them. The looked like "savages" to the English gentlemen, but that's because they were totally different and the Englishmen didn't understand the reasons for what the Indians wore or how they cut their hair. The details were very rich and the story is rife with adventure. There's a sea voyage, fighting with the natives, hunting, and sword fighting. There's a fair share of violence (people getting hit with arrows, dying of illnesses, burning down houses), but it was a violent time.

Reading Carbone's copious author's note, I learned that all the main characters in the story were real people. The events in the story are based on actual events. This won't be a book for everyone, but it would make an excellent companion novel to any kind of study about Jamestown or Virginian Native Americans. I think young history buffs could also get into it, too. It's not a novel to be breezed through, but one to savor so you can soak up all those rich details that the author paid so much attention to. I've said it before and I'm sure I'll say it again, but this is a book I never would have picked up on my own. And I've got to send a big shout-out to the wonderful Illinoisans on the Caudill committee...!

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

i agree with her completly

Anonymous said...

this is good for a summary for school......hahaha.....but i reword it!!!

Anonymous said...

i read this for school and im really glad i did cause it was my favorite book we had to read all year. extremely detailed. and very accurate. fun to read. characters are very likeable too. i really enjoyed it.

Anonymous said...

i aloso had to read it and it was okay but to me, it was kind of confusing like they will be talking aabout one thing then, completely something else pops up.

Anonymous said...

I am only on page 35 ,but love this book already!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

I thought it wasn't to good, but was good for a school book

Anonymous said...

i think this book is confusing.......and im 17. but its kinda good. the naked mole rat letters is a better book by far but what do i know? im repeating my 4th year of 7th grade. :)

Anonymous said...

this book is the best i have read in my whole live!!!!!!!!!!!!
itis awsome and Elisa Carbone is a very accurete writer i loved her book!!

Anonymous said...

this book is awesome!!!!!!!!!!!
it is the best i have ever read
love it

Grace said...

This summary is great. I used this for my students.